Jennifer Turnock's Top Ten Lists for 2002
I first read Nick Hornby's novel About a Boy in late 1999 and loved it to
the point of being annoyingly evangelical about it to friends, family,
casual acquaintances, strangers at the supermarket, what have you. ("I
didn't even know Bruce Hornsby wrote a book, but sure I'll read it if you'll
just shut the hell up about it.") So after a torturous two and a half year
wait, I had prepared myself for the disappointment that would no doubt
result when the movie version inevitably failed to live up to my overly high
expectations. But much to my black little pessimistic heart's surprise, the
adaptated screenplay by Peter Hedges and the brothers Weitz actually
improved on the book in many ways (other than the overly sentimental final
scene).
Hugh Grant has a tough role that requires him to be shallow, selfish and
let's face it - a bit of a dick. But Grant admirably straddles that delicate line between charming rogue and
villain that is so crucial to the overall movie. Nicholas Hoult gives an
unsentimental performance as Marcus, and the chemistry between the
two leads is spot on. Lastly, my compliments for the nicely thought out set
design, costumes and props that reveal so much about the characters and
their inner lives before they even open their mouths to speak.
Igby Goes Down has the benefit of both excellent acting and intelligent,
crackling dialogue. Director/writer Burr Steers shows us a collection of
emotionally damaged, off-kilter misfits reluctantly bound to each other by
literal and symbolic familial ties. The lead character, Igby (brilliantly
played by Kieran Culkin), is constantly getting his ass kicked by the other
characters, emotionally and sometimes even physically. However, in Igby's
case, the audience can see why, since he often acts like a stubborn, self-destructive little brat. I've seen people complain that the movie is flawed
because it has no sympathetic characters. I'd argue that while most of the
characters do and say things that aren't particularly likeable at times,
they still evoke our sympathy as we watch their struggles to come to grips
with their lives and the pain that has been inflicted on them. Steers
doesn't have the same affection for his eccentric characters that a director
like Wes Anderson does, but he does an excellent job of evoking pathos
within the context of a very darkly funny movie.
The Quiet American is currently in theaters and I highly recommend it.
Michael Caine has never been better and the movie itself is thought
provoking, well directed and beautifully shot. Unlike a more conventional
Hollywood movie (or, for that matter, the first film adaptation of Graham
Greene's novel by Joseph Mankiewicz), director Philip Noyce is not afraid to
explore the moral ambiguities of the two main protagonists as they compete
to "win" the same woman. The love triangle itself is compelling largely
because Caine is able to vividly convey the high stakes riding on the
outcome of this contest for his character. However, the real story is in
the subtext that reflects the competition to determine who will shape the
future of the country of Vietnam itself and the often disastrous
consequences that can result from even the best of intentions.
Lastly, Y Tu Mama Tambien is part road trip, part coming of age drama, part
teen sex romp and even part "The Graduate meets How Stella Got Her Groove
Back." On one level the movie is laugh out loud funny and the two teenage
leads are like Beavis and Butthead's non-union Mexican equivalents (and I
mean that in the best possible way). On another level, director Alfonso
Cuarón uses seemingly throwaway background details to tell a hundred little
stories about Mexico itself, both its spirit and its sorrows.
Special Recognition Award #1
Least Attractive Miramax Star to Get a Good, Hard Screwing from Harvey
Weinstein This Year: Michael Caine
Michael Caine gave one of the finest performances of his career in
Miramax's The Quiet American, a movie that was nearly never released
theatrically at all. In what has now become a well known story,
Miramax Dictator-for-Life Harvey Weinstein pulled the scheduled fall
2001 release indefinitely after the events of September 11th, because he
was concerned the movie would be perceived as being too critical of the
US. The release was pushed into the traditional dumping grounds of
January, where it would have been in the illustrious company of quality
movies featuring a sinister tooth fairy and Poochy, the rapping
kangaroo.
Caine eventually shamed Miramax into a very limited Oscar qualifying
release and he's since received an onslaught of critical acclaim.
However, Caine may have won the battle but lost the war. Harvey
apparently doesn't like being the bitch in the relationship, and so far,
he appears to be be withholding the full support of Miramax's legendary
Oscar-buying marketing machine.
Special Recognition Award #2
Best Repeat Performance at Spotting a Future Multi-million Dollar Meal
Ticket: Rita Wilson
Proving that sometimes lightning does indeed strike twice, Rita Wilson
took a frizzy-haired comedian with next to no prior experience, provided a
little extra special nuturing and encouragement and voila - one Big Fat
Greek Wedding later and she's the proud co-owner of a multi-million
dollar pie. Note to MoJo and Zora - this is how it's done in the big
leagues.
Best Picture
|
Position |
Film |
1
|
About a Boy
|
2
|
Igby Goes Down
|
3
|
Y Tu Mama Tambien
|
4
|
Spirited Away
|
5
|
The Quiet American
|
6
|
Frailty
|
7
|
Rabbit-Proof Fence
|
8
|
Nine Queens
|
9
|
Bowling for Columbine
|
10
|
Chicago
|
Best Director
|
Director |
Film |
Phillip Noyce
|
Rabbit-Proof Fence
|
Alfonso Cuarón
|
Y Tu Mama Tambien
|
Hayao Miyazaki
|
Spirited Away
|
Rob Marshall
|
Chicago
|
Chris Weitz and Paul Weitz
|
About a Boy
|
Todd Haynes
|
Far from Heaven
|
Peter Jackson
|
The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers
|
M. Night Shyamalan
|
Signs
|
Burr Steers
|
Igby Goes Down
|
Spike Jonze
|
Adaptation
|
Best Actor
|
Actor |
Film |
Michael Caine
|
The Quiet American
|
Hugh Grant
|
About a Boy
|
Kieran Culkin
|
Igby Goes Down
|
Nicolas Cage
|
Adaptation
|
Leonardo DiCaprio
|
Catch Me If You Can
|
Robin Williams
|
One Hour Photo
|
Bill Paxton
|
Frailty
|
Al Pacino
|
Insomnia
|
Diego Luna
|
Y Tu Mama Tambien
|
Aaron Stanford
|
Tadpole
|
Best Actress
|
Actress |
Film |
Julianne Moore
|
Far from Heaven
|
Everlyn Sampi
|
Rabbit-Proof Fence
|
Maribel Verdú
|
Y Tu Mama Tambien
|
Renée Zellweger
|
Chicago
|
Sigourney Weaver
|
Tadpole
|
Franka Potente
|
The Bourne Identity
|
Jodie Foster
|
Panic Room
|
Emmanuelle Devos
|
Read My Lips
|
Gwyneth Paltrow
|
Possession
|
Best Supporting Actor
|
Actor |
Film |
Chris Cooper
|
Adaptation
|
Christopher Walken
|
Catch Me If You Can
|
Matthew O'Leary
|
Frailty
|
Dennis Quaid
|
Far from Heaven
|
Paul Newman
|
Road to Perdition
|
Eddie Izzard
|
The Cat's Meow
|
Nicholas Hoult
|
About a Boy
|
Brendan Fraser
|
The Quiet American
|
Joaquin Phoenix
|
Signs
|
Robin Williams
|
Insomnia
|
Best Supporting Actress
|
Actress |
Film |
Samantha Morton
|
Minority Report
|
Queen Latifah
|
Chicago
|
Catherine Zeta-Jones
|
Chicago
|
Patricia Clarkson
|
Far from Heaven
|
Bebe Neuwirth
|
Tadpole
|
Meryl Streep
|
Adaptation
|
Claire Danes
|
Igby Goes Down
|
Joanna Lumley
|
The Cat's Meow
|
Toni Collette
|
About a Boy
|
Amanda Peet
|
Igby Goes Down
|
Best Screenplay
|
Writer(s) |
Film |
Burr Steers
|
Igby Goes Down
|
Fabián Bielinsky
|
Nine Queens
|
Peter Hedges, Chris Weitz and Paul Weitz
|
About a Boy
|
Alfonso Cuarón and Carlos Cuarón
|
Punch-Drunk Love
|
Charlie Kaufman and Donald Kaufman
|
Adaptation
|
M. Night Shyamalan
|
Signs
|
Brent Hanley
|
Frailty
|
Heather McGowen and Niels Mueller
|
Tadpole
|
Scott Frank and John Cohen
|
Minority Report
|
Bill Condon
|
Chicago
|
Best Scene
|
Scene |
Film |
Molly and Daisy tell their story
|
Rabbit-Proof Fence
|
Fowler surveys the damage
|
The Quiet American
|
Will, Marcus and Fiona go to lunch
|
About a Boy
|
Luisa, Tenoch and Julio get drunk and start toasting
|
Y Tu Mama Tambien
|
Sexual Healing
|
I Spy
|
Cell Block Tango
|
Chicago
|
Cat Fight
|
Undercover Brother
|
Killing Me Softly Talent Show Performance
|
About a Boy
|
"It's Happening"
|
Signs
|
Rachel dresses up for lunch with D.H.
|
Igby Goes Down
|
Best Use of Music
|
Position |
Film |
1
|
About a Boy
|
2
|
Undercover Brother
|
3
|
8 Mile
|
4
|
Rabbit-Proof Fence
|
5
|
Spirited Away
|
6
|
Chicago
|
7
|
The Quiet American
|
8
|
Catch Me If You Can
|
9
|
Igby Goes Down
|
10
|
Y Tu Mama Tambien
|
Worst Picture
|
Position |
Film |
1
|
Austin Powers in Goldmember
|
2
|
Men in Black II
|
3
|
The Transporter
|
4
|
Dragonfly
|
5
|
My Big Fat Greek Wedding
|
6
|
Star Wars Episode II: Attack of the Clones
|
7
|
Sweet Home Alabama
|
8
|
Mothman Prophecies
|
9
|
Two Week's Notice
|
10
|
Possession
|
Best Cast
|
Position |
Film |
1
|
Far from Heaven
|
2
|
Y Tu Mama Tambien
|
3
|
Igby Goes Down
|
4
|
Adaptation
|
5
|
Chicago
|
6
|
Rabbit-Proof Fence
|
7
|
About a Boy
|
8
|
The Quiet American
|
9
|
Insomnia
|
10
|
Road to Perdition
|
Best Overlooked Film
|
Position |
Film |
1
|
Igby Goes Down
|
2
|
Y Tu Mama Tambien
|
3
|
Spirited Away
|
4
|
The Quiet American
|
5
|
Frailty
|
6
|
Nine Queens
|
7
|
Rabbit-Proof Fence
|
8
|
Bowling for Columbine
|
9
|
Brotherhood of the Wolf
|
10
|
The Cat's Meow
|
Return to the 2003 Calvin Awards