2010 Calvin Awards: Best Director
February 12, 2010
The directors of animated films don't often get the love they should. Sure, we all know the top three names on this list, but if you ask the average man on the street who Pete Docter is, he's probably not going to be able to tell you that Docter directed Monsters, Inc. and co-directed Up. BOP thinks that Docter and his cohort Bob Peterson deserve all kinds of praise for the art they created with Up, taking the audience from the simple home of a senior citizen to the jungles and rain forests of South America. The humans in the film (Carl Fredricksen, Russell and Charles F. Muntz) are all perfectly rendered to compliment their personalities, and the animals (Kevin the bird and Dug and the other dogs) are like no characters we've seen before. The opening minutes of the film tell a fully formed story in their own right – one that brought many people to real tears. What better vision could you ask for?
A similar fully formed world comes from our fifth place finisher, Neill Blomkamp. District 9 puts the audience in the middle of a South Africa that has moved some stranded aliens to a ghetto area where they are policed and monitored on a regular basis. He infuses the aliens – even though they look like bugs or "prawns" – with life and personality. He seamlessly blends drama, action and a political message. It's a highly original science fiction film from a director who has a bright future in the industry.
Sixth and seventh place go to Jason Reitman for Up in the Air and J.J. Abrams for his reboot of Star Trek. A lot of people have commented that Up in the Air is all about the performances, but it's a complete film that truly evokes the loneliness and sadness that comes over its lead character as he grows throughout the story. It's a movie I still think about a lot, in fact. As for Star Trek, Abrams had a tall order in front of him. It was going to be tough to make a new Star Trek that could appeal both to old fans and newcomers to the franchise, but he pulled it off completely, with room to grow.
Our final three spots in the top ten might surprise you, as they belong to Wes Anderson (Fantastic Mr. Fox), Henry Selick (Coraline) and Todd Phillips (The Hangover). Anderson is known for the detail and precision he presents in his films, and he transitions that talent to the world of stop-motion animation with ease. Selick also operates in stop-motion, coincidentally, and Coraline deftly combines the every-day and mundane with the nightmare world where the Other Mother prevails. Finally, with The Hangover, Phillips has once again delivered a hilarious comedy that delivers from start to finish.
Just missing out on the top ten this year were Lee Daniels (Precious), Spike Jonze (Where the Wild Things Are), Zack Snyder (Watchmen) and Lars Von Trier (Antichrist). While BOP is largely onboard with the critical favorites of the year, it's clear to see that we have our own unique picks that are worthy of praise. (Kim Hollis/BOP)
Best Actor Best Actress Best Album Best Breakthrough Performance Best Cast Best Director Best DVD Best Overlooked Film Best Picture Best Scene Best Screenplay Best Supporting Actor Best Supporting Actress Best TV Show Best Use of Music Best Videogame Worst Performance Worst Picture
Top 10
|
Position |
Director(s) |
Film |
Total Points |
1 |
Kathryn Bigelow |
The Hurt Locker |
121
|
2 |
James Cameron |
Avatar |
113
|
3 |
Quentin Tarantino |
Inglourious Basterds |
86
|
4 |
Pete Docter and Bob Peterson |
Up |
78
|
5 |
Neill Blomkamp |
District 9 |
66
|
6 |
Jason Reitman |
Up in the Air |
56
|
7 |
J.J. Abrams |
Star Trek |
44
|
8 |
Wes Anderson |
Fantastic Mr. Fox |
39
|
9 |
Henry Selick |
Coraline |
36
|
10 |
Todd Phillips |
The Hangover |
30
|
Continued:
1
2
|
|
|
|