New at BOP: Review: Matrix Resurrections Movie Review: Moonfall Movie Reviews: Scream The #1 Movie in America November Forecast The Many Saints of Newark October Forecast New Trivia Question All site updates Share & Save   Tweet Print this column

Michael Lynderey: I'm not sure that the film will have particularly good legs this time of year, and that's a shame. I enjoyed Ricki, a fairly entertaining crowd pleaser, and I think perhaps a December release date would have suited the film better. In many ways the film is similar to Meryl Streep's It's Complicated, so following a similar release strategy would have made sense, even if the films were never going to have matching box offices.

Ben Gruchow: I agree with Michael about the December time period feeling more appropriate; this is a slight little movie that feels tailor-made for the holiday crowd and not the end-of-summer period. It's the type of thing that would've still opened fairly small, but benefited immensely from the Christmas/New Year's box-office haven.

Kim Hollis: Aardman Animations' Shaun the Sheep earned $4 million this weekend and has $5.6 million since debuting on Wednesday. What do you think of this result?

Felix Quinonez: I think it's fine. I don't think Americans are really the main audiences for Aardman films. The studio seems to agree seeing as how they released the movie in less than 2,500 theaters. They will probably see a nice profit overseas though so it should be a small hit.

Ben Gruchow: This is a little disappointing, and well below Aardman's other U.S. films. StudioCanal is a smaller distributor than Sony or DreamWorks, so I can understand why the venue count was lower than the 3,400-3,700 range of the earlier movies from the studio. 2,320 venues isn't nothing, though; it's more than two of the other three films released this weekend got, and I'm fairly certain (without having seen Ricki and the Flash yet) that it's cozily the best of them. Granted, it's already made $60 million overseas, but Aardman's stop-motion budgets have gone up, and a budget for this one in the $30-$40 million range wouldn't really surprise me. The studio's approach to animation absolutely isn't for everyone; there is no way that this slim 85-minute film isn't better than something like Minions in just about every way. This result is lower than the movie deserves.

Ryan Kyle: It's hard not to call this a terrible opening when even George Lucas's Strange Magic fiasco opened higher back in January. Lionsgate released the film too late in my opinion. Shaun opened in the UK in February (where it made a big chunk of its $60 million overseas gross) and hit DVD shelves there in June, so any diehard Aardman fan already has had plenty of opportunity to see it, surely knocking off of its gross. If anything, it feels as if the US release was a contractual obligation.

There hasn't been any new animation since Minions, which is five weeks old now, so this was a prime frame for Shaun to pop with a higher opening in the $10 million range. There is nothing at all remotely kid friendly until Hotel Transylvania 2 at the end of September, but with an opening in 2,320 theaters and not even cracking the top 10, I don't think venues will keep it around long enough for it to even develop legs. I would blame the lack of success on the marketing, because I honestly had no clue what this movie was about or even heard of it until I saw it listed on Fandango this past week while looking up showtimes.

Edwin Davies: Even though it pains me to see an Aardman film not doing well, I can completely understand why Shaun the Sheep didn't break out. The release seemed to be treated as something of an afterthought - no doubt because the film had already been such a success elsewhere - and wasn't really pushed that hard. It's also an odd film since it's stop-motion, features almost no dialogue, and is aimed at a very young audience so it wouldn't have the cross-generational appeal of even Minions.

More important, the Shaun the Sheep TV series, of which this is a spin-off, doesn't have much of a foothold in the States, so name recognition would have been practically zero. At best, the character would be remember as a supporting player in a short film released 20 years ago. Actually, when you put it that way, $5.6 million doesn't seem that bad.

Continued:       1       2